Black students “banned” from schools!

That’s what the speaker said. African American students from the to-be-closed Manierre Elementary School near our church in Chicago were prevented from enrolling in the nearby magnent and selective enrollment schools. Schools, where the speaker said, whites were the majority race.

Outrageous! This will not stand! Protest and march!

That’s the response the speaker wanted the crowd to have. It was my first response when I learned about the presentation and the assertions. But I’ve spent 16 years as a parent in the very schools the speaker implied as having racist frameworks.

His words were grandstanding. Designed more to incite a crowd than to actually get to some solutions.

The deadline for selective and magnet programs passed December 2012. The children weren’t banned — they were late. Whites comprise about 33% of the population at every school in our vicinity, 60% – 65% being the rest of the city’s tapestry: blacks, hispanic, asian and other.)

It’s no surprise to anyone – of any color – that the education system is failing minorities. According to the CPS website, the 2011 ISAT results show that only 1 in 9 African American elementary students exceed the state standards; the achievement gap between white and black elementary students is more than 31%, with a dramatic increase in the last 5 years. That ratio grows even wider in high school. That growing disparity is outrageous and should not be allowed to continue.

The system is failing to educate, inspire and empower children of color and children of limited means. As Christians and as citizens we must be concerned and engaged in being part of building the beloved community for all God’s people. But we get there not by grandstanding or demagoguing but by working together – all of us.

And here is why I believe the rhetoric on public schools has something to do with our faith: it’s easy to have a “party line” on issues. It’s easy to see the problems and solutions through one lens. It’s easy to paint with a wide brush and blur context, obscure facts and fan suspicions. It’s a lot harder to build a new future.

But a new future is what God is after. We are working for the kingdom of God to come to earth as it is in heaven. And to get there we don’t need mob mentality, we need thoughtful conversations and commitment to a shared future. And not just in the public education realm but on a range of issues (gun control, weaponry sales to Israel, abortion restrictions, immigration reform, to name just a few far ranging and somewhat random topics). I humbly suggest that people of faith could be conversation changers if we could just tone down the volume and work through solutions.

2 thoughts on “Black students “banned” from schools!

  1. I don’t really know a lot about this, I don’t have kids in the system, and I may be missing some context, but late? Weren’t the school closures announced this Spring? Or at least after the December deadline? Maybe some of these families could have seen the writing on the wall, but can we really just chalk it up to the families being late? If this in fact was the timing of it all, it really does leave these families with fewer options, including those nearby schools with December deadlines. “Banned” or “unable to enroll” yields the same results for these families. And in a system that they already thinks works against them, well, this seems like an easy leap.

    I agree with most everything else you shared (I think). I don’t think grandstanding is ever the right thing to do, and I agree that we should help change the conversation. Commitment to a shared future? Absolutely. But I think it’s harder for those whose personal experiences lead them to believe that no one is really committed to their futures.

    I have more to say, but doing this on a cell phone is driving me crazy…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s